Russia after communism andrei shleifer and daniel treisman d uring the 1990s, russia underwent extraordinary transformations. Comintern gave literature, funds and advice to the communist revolutions abroad. In 1921 a naval base in kronstadt revolted against the bolsheviks and war communism. Provisional government factors may include the decision to stay in the war and the rise of the soviets. War communism was the first version of the soviet planned economy. Played no significant part until he met bukharin with whom he wrote the abc of communism. It aimed to abolish private trade, control labour, nationalize all largescale industry, and at its height in 1920 to replace the money system with a universal system of state rationing. International communism between the two world wars 78 6. In addition to nationalization of large firms, war communism involved a nearly a third between 1940 and 1944, with food consumption being reduced. As the name suggests, war communism was introduced to meet.
In the wake of the collapse of communism in the ussr, such arguments are gaining currency even among sections of the revolutionary left. The policys chief features were the expropriation of private business and the nationalization. Any acceptance or accommodation to these views, which are unhistorical and. Communism in russia 1900 to 1940 south african history. Parties of the second international side with their imper. This meant that all industrial and agricultural output was to be geared towards the war effort. Communist party, which became the international communist party in 1964. Bordiga summed up his position on the russian revolution at the end of the first part of russia and revolution in marxist. November 9, 2016 the usual western perception of russia is based on the paradigm of the end of history and universality of the western values and development model. Resolution of the eighth party congress, on the organizational question march, 1919 89. Work was hard and long, food was rationed to only those who worked and trade unions were banned. More exactly, the policy of war communism lasted from june 1918 to march 1921. In this topic, as well as the next, the rise of the two economic systems that dominated the 20th century.
War communism is generally considered to be the overall policy of the soviet. It was the rather moderate set of policies adopted by the early soviet state, in order to provide for the war effort. This book is a richly detailed account of the russian revolution from the fall of the tsar in. War communism to win the civil war and impose communism in russia, lenin needed a strong red army supplied with weapons and food. These people became more and more angry about the war and said bitter and critical things about the soviet leaders. Sovnarkom sovnarkom is the russian term for council of peoples commissars and became the governing apparatus in russia. What was the link between the 1905 and 1917 revolutions. The policys chief features were the expropriation of.
Russia from 1918 until 1921 has gone into history under the name. What did lenin and stalin contribute to communism in. World war i, the czars poor leadership, and rioting in petrograd. Shortly after he joined the editorial board of pravda, and in 1920 he was elected to the secretariat of the party central committee. At first, the russian communists did not try to force other communist parties to agree with them. High price but bolsheviks wanted an end to war to consolidate power at home and deal with opponents of 1917 october revolution.
With vladimir lenin at the helm, the bolsheviks, ascribing to marxism, seize power during russia s october revolution and become the first communist government. The russian perception of the postcold war era and relations with the west by dmitry suslov. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. War communism was introduced by lenin to combat the economic problems brought on by the civil war in russia. Written to support gcse teaching but also used as extension enrichment and flipped activities at ks3 1. In russia, communism began after tsar nicholas ii lost his power during the february revolution. Distinguished historian of the soviet period robert v. What started in 1917 russia, became a global revolution, taking root in countries as far flung as china and korea to kenya and sudan to cuba and nicaragua. Bbc history filesoviet communism and the cold war ep1,3. Communist russia or the soviet union became the focus of cold war tensions and animosities. Whereas marx had predicted that capital ism would mature into a proletarian revolt and then a socialist dictatorship, the architects of the new russia sought to skip key marxian historical steps.
How was communism applied in russia under lenin and stalin. The provisional government was established under prince lvov, however, the bolsheviks refused to accept the government and revolted in october 1917, taking control of russia. Russia was for many centuries separated, geographically and politically, from the development of western civilization and culture, and thus came late into what, for most of europe, would be called the modern age. Robert service traces the rise and fall of communist russia, whose mission to export socialist revolution rippled through world politics across a century. The policy was ended in 1921 because it was not successful. Lih when people reflect on the fate of russia in the twentieth century, the y sometimes find the key to an explanation in war communism, the name given by th e bolsheviks after the fact to the economic policies adopted during the civil war of 19181921. The fanaticism of the leaders, the growing brutalization of the rankandfile on both sides of. What factors and events led to the russian revolution. Lenin, ruler of revolutionary russia, stood before the tenth congress of the bolshevik party and dramatically admitted that something had gone awry with the revolution. Kgb defectors cold war secrets revealed at last this article is more than 5 years old vasili mitrokhins demand granted 20 years on.
They demanded new elections, freedom of speech, freedom of trade unions and the right to private property. War communism is the name for the economic policies that introduced to russia in 1918 by vladimir lenin, leader of russia from 191724. Many of these disabled soldiers veterans known as afghantsy were not from russia, but were citizens of the countries russia controlled through the ussr like czechoslovakia and romania. Us and soviets vied for global domination and tried to pull the rest of the world into the war. This pdf is a selection from an outofprint volume from the national bureau 186070. As the ideas of karl marx circulated through europe in the late 1800s, they found their way into russia. The state took control of the factories and appointed managers to run them. The civil war caused the bolsheviks to adopt a more severe economic policy known as war communism, characterized chiefly by the expropriation of private business and industry and the forced requisition of grain and other food products from the peasants.
The second revolution in russia 1 9 1 4 march 1 9 7 1. Russia the civil war and war communism 191821 britannica. Whereas marx had predicted that capital ism would mature into a proletarian revolt and then a socialist dictatorship, the architects of the new russia. War communism was the name given to the economic system that existed in russia from 1918 to 1921. Robert conquest considers that war communism was entirely in line with bolshevik precepts, and that far from being a war measure the war communism policy was a conscious attempt to create a new social order. Communism launched from lenins october revolution and spread to china with mao zedong s rise to power and to cuba, with fidel castros takeover. Vladimir lenin, their leader, rose to power and governed between 1917 and 1924. Decree on nationalization of largescale industry june 28, 1918 81 western radicals on the communists. Russia agreed to give up lots of territory with natural resources. Communist takeover and hoped to bring russia back into wwi. Marxism russia before 1917 the russian revolutions. History of the communist party of the soviet union 1939. The effects of war communism write a letter to a middle class relative in america who fled russia after the bolsheviks seized power in 1917.
A resource for my year 8 students about communist russia. Richard pipes russia under the bolshevik regime takes a different approach. Bbc history filesoviet communism and the cold war ep1,3,4 and 5. The february and october 1917 revolutions unit 2 page 9 civil war and war communism unit 3 page 22 russia. The russian perception of the postcold war era and. How people in the cities are faring, particularly the middle classes. In march 1918 russia signed peace treaty with the germans. Both had seen how lenin had resolved the crisisby first invoking an alliance with the medium peasants, and then with all. Supported war communism and spoke about the depreciation of the currency as a factor leading to the abolishment of classes. Rosa luxemburg, the russian revolution 1918 82 the party program of 1919 85 centralization of the communist party. Poland, ukraine, finland, latvia, estonia, lithuania l. It was a combination of emergency measures and socialist dogma. Unfortunately, this change increased worker control but led to a major fall in production and had to be abandoned in favour of war communism.
The bolshevik party was committed to the political ideology of communism, or socialism. Introduction to communist russia teaching resources. For many years they fought the west in what is today called the cold war. He even suggested that he be removed from his job as secretary of. The russian empire at this time was ruled by an autocratic tsar who refused to share political power, believing his. Communism means war of the most ruthless character, the. The writings of karl marx what led to the 1905 revolution. War communism or military communism was the economic and political system that existed in soviet russia during the russian civil war from 1918 to 1921. How 1917 shaped a century the state created by the bolsheviks after the toppling of the romanov monarchy in 1917 survived two world wars and beyond.
Surplus crops were taken by the government to feed the workers and soldiers. According to soviet historiography, the ruling bolshevik administration adopted this policy with the goal of keeping towns and the red army stocked with food and weapons since circumstances dictated extreme measures as the ongoing civil war disrupted normal economic mechanisms and relations. Far from being a war measure the war communism policy was a conscious attempt to create a new social order, to effect the immediate transformation of the country into full socialism. This sequel to the harvard historians the russian revolution, completes the trilogy he began some twenty years ago with his russia under the old regime. But a deeper problem, less often addressed, is the real nature of the soviet system that was finally swept away. Trotsky and the red army attacked the sailors and thousands on both sides died. The imposition of communist rule in russia in october 1917, led by lenin and his bolsheviks, began seventy years of close governmental control on all aspects. Although the term sounds red, it was actually a very conservative policy that put leninist ideology in the background while imp. War communism, in the history of the soviet union, economic policy applied by the bolsheviks during the period of the russian civil war 191820. The book covers the period from the outbreak of the civil war.
640 1184 1114 705 637 154 131 527 1213 451 1180 1240 537 353 249 1516 598 1195 590 315 841 997 739 309 290 1412 391 751 1523 1340 179 792 733 858 1191 842 771 1313 1025 877 634 1055 486 417 40